Darkness of Victory: The Communist Factor in World War II
In April 1945, the Nazi Third Reich was on its last legs. Triumphant armies from multiple countries were advancing on German soil from all directions. Among the proudest were none other than the troops of the Soviet Union as they captured Hitler’s lair, Berlin. Nearly four years earlier, in 1941, the Führer had launched an invasion of the USSR in an attempt to exterminate its people and plunder its territory. Twenty-six million Russians and other Soviet nationalities did not survive.
But beyond the sheer human cost of what many former Soviet states now remember as the “Great Patriotic War,” a less-than-heroic story provides sobering context for the most brutal military campaign of the Second World War.
The epic of national survival celebrated so greatly in Russia and other countries every May 9 overshadows—but does not erase—a base exercise in communist aggression, atrocity, and betrayal.
In the immediate prewar years, Adolf Hitler’s coercive diplomacy had absorbed Austria into the Nazi Reich and split Czechoslovakia into a Nazi-controlled Czech protectorate and a fascist Slovak puppet state. Poland was next, and Soviet dictator Josef Stalin had agreed to take part.
Days before German tanks blitzed Poland from the west, Stalin’s foreign minister Vyacheslav Molotov had signed a secret treaty with his Nazi counterpart, Joachim von Ribbentrop. On Sept. 1, 1939, Germany launched Case White—its name for the invasion of Poland. Seventeen days later the Soviets attacked from the east.
The USSR not only joined the German invasion of Poland but also supplied the Reich with crucial shipments of vital petroleum and other materials as Rommel’s tanks swept through the Low Countries and France—and as Wehrmacht divisions occupied the Balkans and North Africa.
At the same time, Soviet troops annexed or attacked five other sovereign countries: Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, Finland, and Romania.
By the time of the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941, the Soviet secret police had deported hundreds of thousands of people from its new territories. In particular, hundreds of thousands of Poles—mainly military personnel, clergymen, and public administrators—were murdered by the Soviet regime, adding to the millions of total Polish dead.
Communism at War
The Soviet Union was compelled to cooperate with the Allied powers after the Nazi empire it had mistakenly aided revealed its true colors. With generous resources from the West, the Red Army not only bore the brunt of fighting against the German military, but proved capable of mounting the massive tank campaigns that propelled it to Berlin—and allowed Stalin to subjugate the peoples of Eastern Europe under their own Soviet-style regimes.
Aside from hundreds of thousands of individuals killed for political reasons, millions of common people, from Germany to Korea, found themselves raped, robbed, deported, or murdered by the communist “liberators.”
The Soviet people themselves suffered dearly as a direct result of first their rulers’ opportunism, and then the senselessly brutal measures with which the Communist Party and Red Army drove them to a bittersweet victory.
Much of Hitler’s initial success was Stalin’s own doing. Starting in 1937, the Soviet communist regime embarked on a ruthless and deadly purge of the Red Army’s higher officers. Dozens of generals, including those working on advanced variations of the German blitzkrieg strategy, were tortured and shot. Others, such as the famed Marshal Gregory Zhukov, were made to serve minor roles while Stalin’s yes-men filled the top positions.
This was a nightmare for Soviet armies stationed in dense formation at the frontline in 1941—and tens of millions of civilians in Hitler’s path. The Wehrmacht cut through the poorly led and unprepared Red Army with ease; German troops took several million prisoners in the opening weeks of the war. The vast majority ended up in Nazi death camps where they were worked to death or shot by the thousands. Soviet prisoners make up the second biggest group of Holocaust victims, after Jews.
Nazi brutality was matched and sometimes surpassed by the callous disregard Soviet commanders had for their own men. Instead of making strategic retreats to conserve manpower, Stalin and his officers gave the infamous Order 227—a short decree that forbade retreat even to avoid encirclement.
“Ni shagu nazad”—Russian for “not one step back” is often romantically seen as a testament to the dictator’s will to resist the enemy but better remembered as Stalin’s refusal to accept the reality of the war. The order led to the senseless slaughter of countless Russians.
Entire secret police divisions—complete with their own tanks and artillery—were set aside not to fight the Germans, but to attack and destroy Soviet formations retreating under Nazi fire.Related Coverage
Soviet leaders regarded those captured by the Germans as traitors. Those who had the misfortune of somehow making it back to Soviet territory found themselves put on trial and pressed into service with penal battalions—the so-called Soviet strafbattalion modeled on the Nazi concept of the same name.
Officers and men who formed these battalions received substandard equipment, no reinforcements, and were used for suicide missions. In an extreme example recounted by a Soviet defector in the Cold War, men were made to act as machine-gunners in the rear position of combat aircraft—they were chained to their weapons and had no parachutes. Others were deployed en masse to run across minefields to clear them for following armies.
The Consequences of ‘Liberation’
Much has been made of Stalin’s cooperation with the Nazi menace, though the full picture may only be gleaned when the Kremlin archives are declassified fully.
A common interpretation of events tells us the Soviet dictator was unimpressed with the West’s indecision in the face of Hitler’s prewar aggression and saw little gain in taking a stand without support from the democracies. Scholars of military history generally agree that the Red Army was severely weakened by communist purges, and was unprepared to wage war when it came.
Other research suggests that were it not for the unfortunate timing of the Nazi invasion, the Red Army would have rapidly completed important military reforms and introduced new weapons.
Proponents of this view, particularly post-Soviet-era scholars in Russia, submit that existing Soviet doctrine called for an all-out invasion of Europe at a time of Stalin’s choosing—that it was for this end, not simple defense, that he extended an olive branch to Berlin.
Regardless of what the Soviet leadership hoped to achieve with pro-Nazi diplomacy, the myth of the USSR as an ally of freedom at any point in World War II is ill-founded. One need look no further than the postwar fates of Eastern Europe and Northern Asia.Related Coverage
Marauding Soviet troops, initially welcomed as liberators, were allowed and sometimes encouraged by their commanders to loot their host nations and gained an unexaggerated reputation as prolific rapists. Meanwhile, millions of Soviet soldiers and civilians—1.5 million of them repatriated by British authorities— became fresh fodder for the labor camps as Stalin continued his prewar despotism.
But the most deleterious and persisting consequence of Soviet “liberation,” both in the east and west, was political. Stalinist regimes imposed from Moscow shackled the fledgling nation-states of Eastern Europe for over 40 years. In Asia, the Soviet lightning offensive against Imperial Japanese colonies in China and Korea directly contributed to the unlikely triumph of the local communists. Over 70 years and hundreds of millions of victims later, these regimes are still in power.
Communism is estimated to have killed around 100 million people, yet its crimes have not been fully compiled and its ideology still persists. Epoch Times seeks to expose the history and beliefs of this movement, which has been a source of tyranny and destruction since it emerged.
Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Epoch Times.